Giving students the opportunity to cope with disappointment has the capacity to shape their good character.

Schools are inherently hopeful and happy places. Their natural focus on growth, connectedness and preparing youth for a better future creates an optimistic atmosphere in which ambitions are born. These positive emotions and experiences lay the foundation for our expectations and while these can be highly motivating, they come with a catch: the greater our expectations, the greater the disappointments, too.

Disappointment is not a popular feeling. Rightly so, not many of us wish to feel sad, displeased or frustrated by the non-fulfilment of our hopes or expectations. However, in an academic setting, disappointments are inevitable and they can manifest in various forms. Commonly, students can find it hard to understand a concept that they see their peers comprehending and receive a lower-than-desired assessment result. Even worse, they can feel “robbed” of a grade that they believed to be rightfully theirs, not be with their preferred teacher, fall short of the required points for an academic award and face unexpected obstacles that disrupt their learning. Invariably, students will experience one or more of these things at some point in their schooling, possibly all of them, often.

(L-R) Year 9 Engineering Students Michael Kelly, Will Browett and Adrian Gray

For parents, it can be incredibly difficult to watch our children experience these things, especially when they result in further negative emotions such as shame or self-loathing. Sometimes, the worry we feel for our children is almost unbearable and it is natural to want to fix the problem for them. Prominent clinical psychologist, Dr Judith Locke is a leading voice on this topic. In her article, Kids need to fail. And parents need to let them; she says, “When your child is disappointed, it’s understandable you want them to feel better immediately, but taking temporary bad feelings away makes your child less capable to face inevitable trickiness in the future.” Locke goes on to say, “While I know it feels awful to watch your child be disappointed or sad, every time you help them avoid those feelings, you also sidestep them learning essential skills of resilience and a belief they will cope if life doesn’t always go their way.”

Sport is a great leveler, filled with both triumph and disappointment

For these reasons, we will not shield students from experiencing disappointment at TGS. Doing so would be detrimental to their development and this fails to prepare them for the realities of life. Most importantly, giving students the opportunity to cope with disappointment has the capacity to shape their good character. As beautifully put by Irish politician Sir Boyle Roche, “Disappointment is the nurse of wisdom.”

I sought the wisdom of some of our older TGS students who have learned to manage their disappointments over time and even harness them for good. Specifically, I surveyed recipients of diligence awards because these recognise dedication and resilience rather than grades. All the respondents admitted to encountering setbacks and shared various versions of not letting these deter their efforts. One of the seniors said, “When faced with disappointment, I use ‘failure’ as a motivator to strive for improvement and apply the feedback I receive to make adjustments for the future.”

“Many of the respondents spoke of controlling the controllables across six broad themes: Consistency and Routine, Using Study Tools, Environment Control, Intrinsic Motivation, Resilience and Perspective.”
Mrs Crystal Hede, Director of Learning and Innovation
  • Consistency and Routine: Diligent students emphasised the importance of sticking to a structured study schedule. They often study at the same time every day and for consistent durations to build a habit of regular learning.
  • Using Study Tools: Many of these students use study trackers, whiteboards and diaries to reinforce learning and ensure they systematically cover all necessary material.
  • Environment Control: They create and maintain separate spaces for study and relaxation to condition their minds for productive work when in the study zone. This includes removing any electronic devices from the study area.
  • Intrinsic Motivation: Consistently, the diligent students spoke of a strong internal drive to improve and put in the effort required to overcome academic hurdles. This includes proactively seeking clarification or help.
  • Resilience: Their responses demonstrated resilience in the form of a “bounce back” mentality. They spoke of accepting that not all decisions will be to their liking (for example, class allocations), acknowledging their negative emotions and then moving on in order to stay focused on their learning.
  • Perspective: Maturely, some of the boys spoke about managing their expectations. While hopes and dreams can be powerful motivators, it’s important to balance them with realistic expectations to maintain a healthy mindset.

TGS Old Boy (2011-13) and 2024 Paris Olympic medalist, Matthew Denny recently spoke with our students, sharing some anecdotes and advice that aligned with the above sentiments. He said that one of the biggest things he learned from his career was that “Success lies on the other side of discomfort. You just need to step toward it and keep moving.” Matthew’s wise words support the notion that disappointment — a form of discomfort — is a natural and expected part of life that forms our character as we strive towards our goals and aspirations. With this in mind, our TGS boys need to keep dreaming but expect that disappointment will occur. They need to keep moving and trying and see disappointment as an opportunity for learning.

Reference

Locke, J. (2019, March). Kids need to fail. And parents need to let them. The Courier Mail. Retrieved September, 2024, from https://www.couriermail.com.au/rendezview/kids-need-to-fail-and-parents-need-to-let-them/news-story/5df007cfd72f50b4a22b03c39c127781


Latest Blog

Character & Wellbeing
/
Thursday, 05 Dec 2024

“Watch your character, it becomes your destiny.”

Whether it was American essayist Ralph Waldo Emerson, Chinese philosopher Lao Tzu, or even UK Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher’s father who coined the phrase “watch your character, it becomes your destiny,” it was Dr Linda Evans who gave it real relevance to a theatre full of students, staff and families. After a decade and a half in charge of Toowoomba’s respected Fairholme College as Principal and some 22 years in total on staff, Dr Evans will leave the institution she has led and loved by…

Read More
Boarding
/
Thursday, 28 Nov 2024

Preparation for Boarding: Practical Tips and Tricks

In fact, I’ve coined the phrase “the clearer the runway, the smoother the landing” as a neat summary of this observation. A great deal of boarding experience can be initiated at home in the weeks and months leading up to your son’s departure, helping him prepare psychologically and logistically for his upcoming journey. At TGS, we acknowledge that the boarding journey for boys and families starts long before they enter the house in late January. In the mind of a new boarder and their family,…

Read More
Character & Wellbeing
/
Thursday, 14 Nov 2024

Exploring the Role of Neuroscience in Supporting Teenage Boys

Recent insights from neuroscience reveal that the teenage brain undergoes significant changes, particularly in the frontal lobe, which is essential for decision-making, impulse control and emotional regulation. By leveraging this knowledge, we can create supportive environments that guide our boys through the complexities of their teenage years.The Prefrontal Cortex The prefrontal cortex, located in the frontal lobe, is one of the last areas of the brain to mature, significantly impacting…

Read More
Character & Wellbeing
/
Thursday, 07 Nov 2024

Wellbeing and Character Development Program — Benefiting Students and Staff Alike

In 2024, the School re-established the Head of Pastoral Care position. The role will be pivotal in supporting all staff to foster a supportive and nurturing environment at Toowoomba Grammar School. Integral to the role’s success is the parallel expansion of the Wellbeing and Character Development (WCD) program to yield multifaceted benefits for both staff and students. For staff, the Head of Pastoral Care provides guidance, support and resources, aiding in their efforts to address students’…

Read More
Character & Wellbeing
/
Thursday, 31 Oct 2024

Nurturing the Seeds of Leadership

Early exposure to leadership roles helps children develop character traits such as responsibility, empathy, resilience and integrity. As a School, we provide the opportunity for the cultivation of leadership skills in our young boys. From the formative years in Prep through to the adolescent years of Year 6, the importance of fostering leadership qualities cannot be overstated. In our modern world, where adaptability, resilience and initiative are regarded as quality attributes, nurturing the…

Read More
Sports & Activities
/
Thursday, 24 Oct 2024

Pedal Power: The TGS Mountain Bike Club

What started with 12 boys now has 90, with many of the riders racing in the Schools Academy Gravity Enduro Series and other events. We also have a tour of 20 boys going to Thredbo in December this year, where they will tackle some of the most exciting trails in Australia. We thank the wonderful group of parents who support the club. They can often be found driving vehicles up and down the range on a Sunday morning to support the boys. We would not have been as successful as we are without…

Read More
Teaching & Learning
/
Thursday, 17 Oct 2024

Beyond the Blue and Gold

Our focus is to work with each individual student to assist in creating awareness of the world of work, helping students to articulate their interests and identifying what is important to them and their values. We assist the boys in developing the skills to explore the different careers out there. We connect them with employers and industry professionals and help them navigate towards the job or career they are interested in. We work hard to individualise each student’s unique School journey to…

Read More
Character & Wellbeing
/
Thursday, 10 Oct 2024

Character and Wellbeing – The Grammar Way

Legacy of Leadership: The Impact of John Mackintosh at Toowoomba Grammar School Toowoomba Grammar School’s first Headmaster, John Mackintosh (1876–1879) led the School with the demeanour of a typical Victorian father figure. His leadership was steadfast and nurturing, with decisions that were definitive and meticulously aimed at creating an environment that was conducive to a boy’s character and learning outcomes. Mackintosh introduced recreational activities such as chess and draughts…

Read More
Teaching Excellence
/
Thursday, 03 Oct 2024

2024 IBSC Conference

It is part of our Strategic Plan's People Pillar which is "build a high-performing culture that supports the wellbeing and development of staff, who exemplify the TGS values and share our commitment to the growth of our boys". In fact, that focus was acknowledged in our receiving The Educator’s 2024 5-Star Employer of Choice award. The Award acknowledges excellence in providing professional development opportunities and nurturing a culture of inclusion and respect. So it was with great pleasure…

Read More