I recently read an article by Petra Stock, entitled "Streaming Stories: Will Children’s Digital Book Platforms Upend Print", an interesting discussion comparing ebooks and print media and the ways they are being used during and post COVID.
Which is better according to the article? Well, there is a clear winner; however, like many things, the answer can depend on the situation. I'd like to break elements of the article down, along with my own thoughts and compare the two.
Social connectivity
When print books are read to young children, there is a social connectivity, that is less present than when digital texts are read. This continues in school, where students will read with their class or teacher, digital texts are more likely to be an independent experience.
Winner: Print
Screen time
One of the greatest concerns among parents is the amount of screen time children have today; while digital books may be “guilt free” screen time, it is nonetheless still time on a screen.
Winner: Print
Comprehension
All things being equal, where a book has the illustrations and text scanned to a digital format; studies have shown that readers who engage with print, read with greater concentration and deeper understanding, whereas reading on a screen tends toward quick shallow scanning behaviour.
Winner: Print
Interactivity
Where a book has been designed for digital consumption or has added features, such as interactivity, animation, music and so on, readers may engage more closely with the text, these books have the potential to improve learning.
Winner: Digital
Dynamic
Print books, once printed are static, you cannot change the font, the background, or the text size. Digital books have accessibility features built in so that you can tailor the experience to your own personal tastes or needs in a given situation. Some ebooks also have the capacity to supply a reader to the text.
Winner: Digital
Physicality
Physical books have the opportunity to play with size and physicality in way that digital texts cannot. A digital text presents everything at the size of the screen you are using, and, while you may be able to zoom in and out, you are changing the whole page. Where a physical book about “tiny things” could be printed in a tiny size or vice versa.
Winner: Print
Convenience
The majority of people carry the capacity to read digitally with them everywhere they go, as a phone, tablet or laptop can be used to read books, and not just one, there is access to almost limitless digital texts online. I could easily carry the entire ‘Wheel of Time’ on my phone, a task I would struggle with in print.
Winner: Digital
Preference
Despite lockdowns during the pandemic, paperbook sales for 2020 – 2021 were approximately 66 million, an 8% rise over the previous years. There is just something, almost theatrical about reading a book, holding it in your hands, engaging your sense of touch, smell and sight. Paperbacks have proven to be the most popular format for readers, followed by hardback and then electronic forms.
Winner: Print
While print, is the clear winner in the article, if you enjoy an e-book, or find it more convenient to carry, or listen to an audiobook while doing other tasks, please don’t feel like these are bad or less desirable. Reading is reading, and reading is good! Perhaps, though, mix it up a bit and try a physical book, visit your library, an op-shop or bookstore. Compare your experiences, engage with both, you may just find a new way to experience and engage with reading.
Latest Blog
REACH - Character Development in the Junior School
Being a kind person is fundamental to the growth of a successful person. Adults in our young men’s lives have a responsibility to model and teach the importance of respect, accepting and acknowledging our need to contribute to society in a positive and meaningful way. In 2016, the Junior School staff felt there was a need to create a program that allowed us to develop the character of the boys in the Junior School. Tailoring a program to meet our boys’ needs rather than a generic one allows…
The Grass is Always Greener
It’s time we put this age-old rumour to rest once and for all… The Toowoomba Grammar School ovals are not painted, dyed or manufactured grass; rather, the glorious green that greets passers-by as they drive into the Garden City comes from the sheer hard work and dedication of our TGS grounds team, led by Danny Beresford. Danny has exceptional pride for his grounds and a strong family connection to TGS. He is an Old Boy (2002-04) who played for the 1st XV in 2004 and was in the Track and Field…
A life in Words - Reading Biographies
Biography; from the Greek Bios - Life & Graphia - Writing; are books that chronicle the lives of real people. The subject of a Biography can be a celebrity, athlete, politician, athlete, historical figure or ordinary person that has achieved something of note. Reading Biographies is a valuable and oftentimes rewarding experience, with many potential benefits to the reader. Inspirational Biographies often recount successes and struggles of those people who have, over the course of their…
Spielberg in the Making...
I first became aware of film making when my brother showed me the behind-the-scenes featurette on our Lord of the Rings DVD. From then on, the process intrigued me, and I eventually got my hands on my dad’s camera and simple editing software. I made a bunch of little movies with my friends which were all pretty bad but I loved doing them anyway. What I liked most was that it was an easy way to share stories and even when the movies were not good, it was still a way of telling stories in a…
The Best Job in the World
Vocational Education and Training (V.E.T) plays a central role in preparing young people for work, developing skills, and responding to the labour-market needs of the economy. As the V.E.T Co-Ordinator at Toowoomba Grammar School, I have an immediate and positive influence on our young men’s skills, employability, and career development. I engage with the most amazing young men to guide their career journeys throughout Years 10, 11 and 12. I also have the privilege to work closely with their…
Inclusive and Exclusive Banter and Behaviour
As the School counsellor, who has been working in a variety of education systems, I would like to address a common and important issue that affects many of our teenage boys: banter, teasing, and bullying. Boys at this age are especially prone to these behaviours, and they can have a significant impact on their mental health and overall well-being. One of the most common mistakes for teenage boys "it's just banter" or "I'm just joking." While banter can be a positive thing and can help build…
I Have Returned to Where it Began and I Feel Right at Home
I have returned to where it all began, and I feel right at home. My parents decided when I was very young that I would attend Toowoomba Grammar School as a boarder. Coming from a property surrounded by a small community, my parents believed that sending me to TGS would provide me with many fundamental skills needed for a young man, as well as an education that I could not get in my hometown.. Starting my journey at TGS in Year 8 as a boarder in Mackintosh, adjusting from a small country high…
Tuning in to TGS Old Boy (1995-99) - Stuart St Vincent Welch
Our Old Boys have such diverse career paths; we are so proud of the good young men they become and how they make meaningful contributions to their communities. Stuart St Vincent Welch describes himself as an average student who had no idea what he wanted to do after school. But drawing on the TGS values of hard work, respect and resilience he is now working as a Sound Engineer for Barking Owl in New York City, rubbing shoulders with some of the world’s most renowned musicians and actors. He…
The TGS Show Cattle Team - On the moooove
The TGS Show Cattle Team commenced in Term 1 2021 under the guidance of Mr Jack Murphy and Mrs Julie Brophy. The concept of the team was to give boys a hands-on, extracurricular opportunity in the agricultural industry. The boys have been competing in the Young Judges’ competitions at a range of shows across Queensland. The Young Judges’ competition is based on the goal of expanding the boys' knowledge of the skills that are a foundation of the animal production industry, helping them as…
